The Hidden Costs of Creative Automation:
Why Sticker Price is Just the Beginning

When procurement teams evaluate creative automation tools, the focus is often on the license cost. On paper, a lower price tag may seem like a win.  

But… The true investment in creative automation extends far beyond the initial purchase.

Creative automation isn’t just a software deployment — it’s a fundamental shift in how marketing and creative teams operate. If businesses focus only on cost-cutting rather than value creation, they risk underutilisation, poor integration, and long-term inefficiencies that ultimately make automation more expensive.

To truly realise the benefits of automation, procurement teams need to think beyond the sticker price. The key to success lies in understanding the total cost of ownership, implementation complexity, and long-term scalability.

The Mistake:
Thinking Automation is Just a Software Purchase

Many procurement teams approach the purchase of automation tools the same way they would any other software — focusing on price, features, and contract terms. However, this mindset overlooks the broader implications of automation.  

Unlike standalone software solutions, creative automation must be deeply embedded into existing workflows. Without proper alignment, businesses risk adopting a tool that creates more friction than efficiency.  

Additionally, automation is not just a one-time purchase — it has to meet the evolving needs of the organisation. Simply put, successful automation isn’t just about acquiring technology, it’s about executing a well-planned transformation that maximises value.

You have to consider the following factors:

• Deep integration into existing workflows — it must work with DAMs, CMSs, project management platforms, and content distribution tools.
• Process transformation — automation changes how teams create, collaborate, and deploy creative assets.
• Cross-functional buy-in — marketing, creative, and IT teams all have a stake in ensuring adoption and ROI.
• Ongoing monitoring and optimisation — automation needs to be continuously refined to stay effective.

A budget-friendly licensing deal means nothing if the tool isn’t fully adopted or can’t scale with business needs.

Beyond the Sticker Price:
The Real Costs of Creative Automation

1. Implementation & Integration

Selecting an automation tool is only the first step—integrating it into existing workflows is where the real challenge begins. Many platforms require custom API development, middleware, and IT support to function effectively. If these costs and efforts aren’t accounted for, the tool can become a drain rather than a driver of efficiency.

Key Considerations:

• Integration complexity can increase IT dependencies and slow adoption.
• Poorly integrated tools create workflow bottlenecks instead of streamlining processes.
• Seamless connectivity with existing MarTech infrastructure is essential for value realisation

Key Questions to Ask:

• ‍How easily does this tool integrate with our existing MarTech stack?
• What additional costs are involved in API development or middleware solutions?
• Does the vendor provide support for seamless integration, or will IT need to step in?

2. Customisation & Workflow Alignment

Every organisation has unique processes, and off-the-shelf automation solutions often fall short of meeting specific needs. Successful automation requires tailored configurations and adaptable workflows to ensure smooth adoption and usability.

Key Considerations:

• Standard automation solutions may not align with existing creative workflows.
• Customisation requirements can lead to extended implementation timelines.
• Overly rigid tools may limit long-term scalability and process innovation.

Key Questions to Ask:

• Will the tool adapt to existing workflows, or will we need to change our processes?
• How much customisation is required to ensure full functionality?
• Does the platform support modular adjustments to suit evolving business needs?

3. Training & Change Management

Adopting a new tool isn’t just about installation—it’s about people. Without structured training and change management, creative teams may resist or fail to fully adopt automation solutions, limiting ROI.

Key Considerations:

• The steeper the learning curve, the longer adoption takes.
• Inconsistent onboarding strategies lead to uneven usage across teams.
• Without strong internal advocacy, automation initiatives can stagnate.

Key Questions to Ask:

• How will we manage the learning curve for our creative and marketing teams?
• What internal training and onboarding costs should we factor in?
• What strategies are in place to ensure long-term adoption and avoid user drop-off?

4. Scalability & Long-Term Cost Traps

Some automation platforms lure companies in with low initial costs but inflate expenses over time as business needs grow. Procurement teams must evaluate pricing structures to avoid unexpected cost spikes.

Key Considerations:

• Licensing fees can scale aggressively based on usage and feature unlocks.
• Long-term reliance on third-party tools can lead to increased vendor lock-in.
• Future scalability should be planned for at the outset to avoid forced migrations later.

Key Questions to Ask:

• What happens to costs if usage increases by 50%?
• Are there hidden fees tied to feature expansion or premium support?
• Does the pricing model align with our anticipated growth?

5. Adoption & Utilisation: The ROI Killer

The best automation tool in the world won’t drive impact if teams don’t use it. Maximising adoption is the single most important determinant of automation success.

Key Considerations:

• Low engagement reduces efficiency gains and nullifies ROI.
• Without clear accountability, tools remain underutilised.
• Continuous optimisation is necessary to maintain relevance.

‍Key Questions to Ask:

• How will we measure adoption success?
• What happens if adoption rates are low — who is accountable for optimisation?
• What incentives or training programs can drive higher engagement?

Procurement Teams:
What Needs to Change

Procurement teams must rethink how they evaluate and invest in creative automation, shifting from a cost-first approach to a value-driven evaluation of creative automation. Too often, purchasing decisions focus on licensing fees while ignoring the broader investment required to ensure a tool’s success.

1. Look Beyond Features & Pricing

Instead of focusing solely on a tool’s features or the initial cost, procurement teams should prioritise how well the solution integrates, scales, and enhances operational efficiency.

2. Prioritise Execution & Usability Over Technical Specs

A tool can have cutting-edge features, but if it’s difficult for creative teams to use, adoption will suffer, and ROI will decline. Automation only delivers value when it is effectively embedded into daily operations.

3. Involve the Right Stakeholders Early

Too often, procurement decisions are made in isolation without input from the creative and marketing teams that will actually use the automation tool. A lack of alignment between procurement, IT, and end-users results in inefficient solutions that fail to deliver ROI.

4. Demand Transparency from Vendors

Not all vendors are upfront about implementation challenges, hidden costs, or long-term limitations. Procurement teams must push for full transparency to avoid surprises after the contract is signed.

‍

It’s Time for a Much More Holistic Approach to Procurement

Success in creative automation doesn’t depend on getting the cheapest license or lowest cost-to-entry — it depends on choosing the right tool for the right use case and ensuring teams can use it effectively.

A short-sighted focus on upfront cost savings can lead to far greater hidden expenses in implementation, workflow adaptation, and lost productivity. And if your procurement team is feeling out of its depth, source a partner to help with critical decision-making.‍

‍ManMachine: Helping You Invest in Execution, Not Just Software

At ManMachine, we help brands, in-house agencies, and marketing teams navigate the complexities of creative automation. Our approach ensures that automation isn’t just purchased — it’s integrated, adopted, and optimised for long-term success.

We don’t just talk about creative automation — we make it work.

‍Here’s how we do it:

• Strategic Implementation — Ensuring automation aligns with your creative workflows from day one.
• Change Management & Training — Supporting teams with the right skills and mindset to fully embrace automation.
• Scalable Solutions — Helping you choose automation tools that grow with your business without hidden cost traps.

Don’t just buy automation. Make your execution seamless with ManMachine.

Speak to us about how we can empower your business or brand’s creative operations and production.